Wiped Reviewed - Revision history

Jon Preddle at 21:35, 5 December 2015

2015-12-05T21:35:19Z

Jon Preddle at 23:30, 24 July 2015

2015-07-24T23:30:44Z

Jon Preddle at 18:53, 30 July 2013

2013-07-30T18:53:35Z

Jon Preddle at 05:29, 9 July 2013

2013-07-09T05:29:25Z

Jon Preddle at 05:21, 9 July 2013

2013-07-09T05:21:53Z

Jon Preddle at 03:04, 29 June 2013

2013-06-29T03:04:58Z

Jon Preddle at 02:49, 29 June 2013

2013-06-29T02:49:54Z

Jon Preddle at 02:49, 29 June 2013

2013-06-29T02:49:21Z

Jon Preddle: Created page with "'''WIPED AGAIN''' Wiped! Updated Edition 2013 ''Review by Jon Preddle'' Richard Molesworth's '''Wiped! Doctor Who's Missing Episodes''' ..."

2013-06-29T02:49:05Z

Created page with "'''WIPED AGAIN''' thumb|200px|right|Wiped! Updated Edition 2013 ''Review by Jon Preddle'' Richard Molesworth's '''Wiped! Doctor Who's Missing Episodes''' ..."

Show changes

← Older revision		Revision as of 21:35, 5 December 2015
Line 147:		Line 147:


−	*'''189-201''': '''THE LIVELY ARTS''': We have a copy of this same set of memos that Richard has accessed, and our own conclusions as to what the various notations on the paperwork means differs widely from Richard's conclusions.	+	*'''189-201''': '''THE LIVELY ARTS''': We have a copy of this same set of memos for '''[[Whose Doctor Who]]''' that Richard has accessed, and our own conclusions as to what the various notations on the paperwork means differs widely from Richard's conclusions.

	:Richard's principal understanding (outlined in his opening four paragraphs) is that the master list (tabulated on pages '''190-197''') was a '''complete''' inventory of the film holdings at Enterprises and the Film Library compiled by an unnamed researcher '''in advance''' of the Lively Arts team going to look at material to use in the '''Whose Doctor Who''' documentary and that they took this already-annotated list with them (i.e. "We have compiled a complete list of the various surviving episodes of Doctor Who that you hold, and we'd now like to have a look at them today, please"). Whereas, our principal understanding is the '''exact opposite''', that the team went along with a ''blank'' list of all episodes made to date that they had themselves compiled but had no idea what was still available (i.e. "These are all the episodes of Doctor Who made to date, we don't know which ones you still have, but we'll look at as many as we can today, please"), and the notations on the master list were added by the two Lively Arts researchers, Ben Shephard and Bridget Cave, '''after''' they had been to Enterprises.		:Richard's principal understanding (outlined in his opening four paragraphs) is that the master list (tabulated on pages '''190-197''') was a '''complete''' inventory of the film holdings at Enterprises and the Film Library compiled by an unnamed researcher '''in advance''' of the Lively Arts team going to look at material to use in the '''Whose Doctor Who''' documentary and that they took this already-annotated list with them (i.e. "We have compiled a complete list of the various surviving episodes of Doctor Who that you hold, and we'd now like to have a look at them today, please"). Whereas, our principal understanding is the '''exact opposite''', that the team went along with a ''blank'' list of all episodes made to date that they had themselves compiled but had no idea what was still available (i.e. "These are all the episodes of Doctor Who made to date, we don't know which ones you still have, but we'll look at as many as we can today, please"), and the notations on the master list were added by the two Lively Arts researchers, Ben Shephard and Bridget Cave, '''after''' they had been to Enterprises.

← Older revision		Revision as of 23:30, 24 July 2015
Line 210:		Line 210:

	*'''201''': Could "the clip of the second Doctor meeting the Daleks in Victorian England" – i.e. [[The Evil of the Daleks]] - that Terrance Dicks apparently viewed in 1976 have actually been the closing moments from [[The Wheel in Space]] part six, in which Kennedy is killed by a Dalek? That particular episode of Wheel is named in the list of recommended clips, so that brief description could simply be identifying the story from which the Kennedy and Dalek "flashback" clip came rather than the title of the actual film print that Dicks had apparently seen.		*'''201''': Could "the clip of the second Doctor meeting the Daleks in Victorian England" – i.e. [[The Evil of the Daleks]] - that Terrance Dicks apparently viewed in 1976 have actually been the closing moments from [[The Wheel in Space]] part six, in which Kennedy is killed by a Dalek? That particular episode of Wheel is named in the list of recommended clips, so that brief description could simply be identifying the story from which the Kennedy and Dalek "flashback" clip came rather than the title of the actual film print that Dicks had apparently seen.
		+	**An alternative is that what Dicks saw was episode 2, then held by the BBC but discarded soon after, and which ultimately resurfaced in early 1987…

@@ Line 5: / Line 5: @@
 Richard Molesworth's '''Wiped! Doctor Who's Missing Episodes''' ([http://www.telos.me.uk/category.php?id=6#141 Telos Publishing Ltd; 2010 and its Updated Edition 2013]) is a remarkable commentary on the sad reality surrounding the fates of the many lost episodes of '''Doctor Who'''.
-We at '''BroaDWcast''' are quite familiar with much of the paperwork that Richard refers to in his tome (we've had access to many of the same documents whilst undertaking the research for this very website; and both this author and the site are acknowledged in the book), so we'd like to throw down a few observations and comments of our own, focussing mainly on those instances where our interpretation of the same paperwork differs, and where we've drawn '''widely different''' conclusions to those drawn by Richard, or where Richard may have overlooked something. A couple of factual errors are also highlighted.
+We at '''BroaDWcast''' are quite familiar with much of the paperwork that Richard refers to in his tome (we've had access to many of the same documents whilst undertaking the research for this very website; and both this author and the site are acknowledged in the book), so we'd like to throw down a few observations and comments of our own, focussing mainly on those instances where our interpretation of the same paperwork differs, and where we've drawn '''widely different''' conclusions to those drawn by Richard, or where Richard may have overlooked something. A couple of factual errors are also highlighted. <!--test-->
 This shouldn't be considered as a criticism of Richard's work, as that certainly is not the intention; if anything, what our observations demonstrate is that when you give the same "evidence" to different people to study, you quite often get different results.

← Older revision		Revision as of 05:29, 9 July 2013
Line 221:		Line 221:

	[[File:ScreenGrabs.JPG\|thumb\|right\|200px\|Two screen shots from The Aztecs – not Marco Polo (page 328)]]		[[File:ScreenGrabs.JPG\|thumb\|right\|200px\|Two screen shots from The Aztecs – not Marco Polo (page 328)]]
−	*'''328''': Only seven of the nine off-screen photos taken in Australia are from [[Marco Polo]]. The two close-up photos of the Doctor are both from [[The Aztecs]], episodes two and four respectively – see our [[Australia TX 1965-1967]] page.	+	*'''328''': Only seven of the nine off-screen photos taken in Australia are from [[Marco Polo]]. The two close-up photos of the Doctor are both from [[The Aztecs]], episodes two (at 8:45) and four (13:00) respectively – see our [[Australia TX 1965-1967]] page.

← Older revision		Revision as of 05:21, 9 July 2013
Line 221:		Line 221:

	[[File:ScreenGrabs.JPG\|thumb\|right\|200px\|Two screen shots from The Aztecs – not Marco Polo (page 328)]]		[[File:ScreenGrabs.JPG\|thumb\|right\|200px\|Two screen shots from The Aztecs – not Marco Polo (page 328)]]
−	*'''328''': Only seven of the nine off-screen photos taken in Australia are from [[Marco Polo]]. The two close-up photos of the Doctor are both from [[The Aztecs]], episodes two and ~~three~~ respectively – see our [[Australia TX 1965-1967]] page.	+	*'''328''': Only seven of the nine off-screen photos taken in Australia are from [[Marco Polo]]. The two close-up photos of the Doctor are both from [[The Aztecs]], episodes two and four respectively – see our [[Australia TX 1965-1967]] page.

← Older revision		Revision as of 03:04, 29 June 2013
Line 1:		Line 1:
−	~~'''WIPED AGAIN'''~~
	[[File:Wiped2nd.jpg\|thumb\|200px\|right\|Wiped! Updated Edition 2013]]		[[File:Wiped2nd.jpg\|thumb\|200px\|right\|Wiped! Updated Edition 2013]]
	''Review by Jon Preddle''		''Review by Jon Preddle''

@@ Line 11: / Line 11: @@
 NOTE: The page numbers cited here are for the 2013 '''Updated Edition'''.
 ----
 *'''47 / 118''': [[The War Machines]]: the serial was film-recorded twice, once in 1966 and again in 1967 or 1968 (Richard isn't always consistent with the date), which was supposedly to furnish the ABC in [[Australia]] with a new set of film prints.